We have chosen this topic because within Scotland, and around the world, history is being used as a weapon of war. Here in Scotland, Facism is a growing force exploiting our lack of knowledge of why things are the way they are, and our experiences of poverty, isolation and disempowerment. This means we target vulnerable groups within our communities instead of those with power. Around the world, genocides, mass displacement and exploitations of people are happening, and many people feel like they don’t understand what's going on or how to help. History gives us crucial information about how things have come to be, an ability to recognise patterns and tools we can use again. It also offers a sense of belonging, not based in violence against, or the exclusion of, others. In this topic we try to understand the role history has in our society and why it matters?
‘No one is going to give you the education you need to overthrow them. Nobody is going to teach you your true history, teach you your true heroes, if they know that that knowledge will help set you free’ - Assata Shakur
In her book ‘The Wee Yellow Butterfly’ Scottish poverty and housing activist Cathy McCormack talked about the ‘War Without Bullets’ in reference to the impacts of the class system on the physical and mental health of our communities. She wanted to draw attention to the impact of less visible oppressions; such as bureaucracy, urban planning and social policy as well as the very tangible realities of uninsulated and mouldy housing. A community organiser and activist all her adult life, Cathy struggled not only with poverty, parenting and trying to force Glasgow City Council to listen to tenants, but also with the impact of what the Kurdish Freedom Movement calls 'special warfare'. This refers to psychological attacks on society - through things like the media pitting communities against each other and social policies which promote isolation and separation. In Cathy’s case in the 90’s this was the rhetoric of ‘benefit scroungers’ and ‘single mums’, today it is ‘stop the boats’ and ‘trans people using toilets’.
It is important to recognise this as a war, because the powers waging it — such as states and corporations — certainly approach it with all the purposefulness and violence of warfare. The aim of this ‘war without bullets’ is to make us feel powerless and alone, to prevent us from understanding ourselves or acting collectively .
As individuals and communities we need self defence, and learning and telling our histories is a world which aims to silence them, is self defence.
“History is the fruit of power, but power itself is never so transparent that its analysis becomes superfluous. The ultimate mark of power may be its invisibility; the ultimate challenge, the exposition of its roots.” ― Michel-Rolph Trouillot, Silencing the Past: Power and the Production of History
To know our history is to know that we are not alone, that we are part of a lineage of struggle and a global community. That we are a link in a chain which will far outlive us. As F Marian McNeill said ‘Remember, no one can face the future with courage and confidence unless it is solidly founded upon the past. And conversely, no problem will be too hard, no situation too strange, if we can link it with what we know and love’. To learn our history is an act of resistance. It offers us hope and the glowing ember of possibility, through the dark times.
Have a gander at the following resources with your group and take a wee bit of time to talk over the following questions together. No need to write anything down - the importance lies in what comes out in the talking.
Why does history matter?
What history do I know and not know?
Who created the histories I know?
How does this impact my sense of self, community or society?
Introduce yourself to a new person/people in pairs or threes.
Mutual care agreement: Chat for a few minutes in pairs, then feedback any key points to group, facilitator writes a list on flipchart.
Frame the conversation. Write your own or use something from our intro above:
We have chosen this topic because within Scotland, and around the world, history is being used as a weapon of war. Here in Scotland, Facism is a growing force exploiting our lack of knowledge of why things are the way they are, and our experiences of poverty, isolation and disempowerment. This means we target vulnerable groups within our communities instead of those with power. Around the world, genocides, mass displacement and exploitations of people are happening, and many people feel like they don’t understand what's going on or how to help. History gives us crucial information about how things have come to be, an ability to recognise patterns and tools we can use again. It also offers a sense of belonging, not based in violence against, or the exclusion of, others. In this topic we try to understand the role history has in our society and why it matters?
‘No one is going to give you the education you need to overthrow them. Nobody is going to teach you your true history, teach you your true heroes, if they know that that knowledge will help set you free’ - Assata Shakur
Looking at a resource, in groups of 5-6. Pick your own local example or use one of our suggestions:
Still in your small groups, discuss:
What is happening in the story/text/image?
What is being shown?
Still in your small groups, discuss:
How does this make you feel?
What are you curious/angry/excited about?
Make your own questions, or use our suggested ones. Focus on questions that help people analyse root causes and how these issues relate to their communities or issues experienced today
What history do I know and not know?
Who created the histories I know?
Show & Tell (based on 3 groups or 5, adjust time if more people)
Each group has 5 mins to do a show and tell - summarising convo about their text/images
Description - what is happening?
Reflection - how do we feel about it?
Analysis - why is this important/relevant?
Full group analysis. Write your own questions or use our suggested ones. ‘Popcorn’ responses where people raise a hand OR go round the room so each person can speak.
Why does history matter?
How does my knowledge of history impact my sense of self, community or society?
Collective Action. Focus on questions that lead to next steps and tangible actions. Write any actions down
What do we want to learn more about?
Who can we build connections with on this issue?
What action could we take?
Reflection prompts. Write down answers so it can inform next session, or SHoR in general
What will you take away from this discussion?
What did you think about the methods we used today to explore this topic?
What could we do differently next time?
Rosie Kane talking about political education at the Pollok Free State followed by Àdhamh Ó Broin talking about Gaelic language resistance. Followed by discussion. Recorded at GalGael during a SHoR event circa January '24.
Podcast #1 - Francesca Sobande on researching Black history and life in Scotland and the role of imagination in history.
2 - Learning History